How He Started the Paid Newsletter Trend — Ben Thompson

How I Write 1h33 5 min #49
How He Started the Paid Newsletter Trend — Ben Thompson
Watch on YouTube

Summary

  • Ben Thompson is the creator of Stratechery, a subscription newsletter about technology, media, and the internet that earns him millions of dollars a year and is widely credited with pioneering the paid newsletter business model. Over more than a decade, he has published roughly 2,500 articles and updates, building a framework-driven approach to analysis that emphasizes storytelling, volume, and a consistent daily publishing schedule. This episode walks through his writing process, business philosophy, and the structural ideas about the internet that underpin his work.

How Stratechery Works as a Business

  • Thompson writes two types of content: free articles on the front page of Stratechery and paid subscriber-only updates published three days a week, plus a Thursday interview podcast.
  • He charges $15 per month (raised from $10 over time) and most of his subscribers are on annual plans, which gives him stable revenue and freedom to write what he wants.
  • His business model depends on high average revenue per user rather than massive scale, and he contrasts his approach with writers like Dylan Patel of Semi Analysis, who charges $500 per year for occasional but extremely high-value scoops.
  • Thompson’s key insight is that he is selling regularity and confidence of delivery, not any single article. Subscribers pay knowing they will get content in their inbox every day.
  • He believes volume is underrated: writing every day for over a decade has been essential to his success, and the daily deadline is a personal productivity hack that forces output even when motivation is low.

The Writing Process

  • Thompson thinks about what he writes constantly throughout the day, not just when sitting down to write. He has an internal framework or “machine” for understanding how the world works, and when news happens, he feeds it into that framework to generate conclusions.
  • Articles (free) are harder to write because they need a compelling hook, must work for unknown audiences with varying background knowledge, and can go viral. Updates (paid) are easier because the audience is self-selected and the opening can be a simple excerpt from a news source.
  • He emphasizes storytelling as a key differentiator: the best pieces have a beginning, a path, and a resolution, even when the core content is analytical.
  • Getting into a flow state is critical. He compares writing to programming: the structure exists in his head, and the act of writing is realizing it. This requires physical separation from family and a dedicated workspace.
  • He rarely starts from scratch. Most articles are articulations, augmentations, or corrections of his existing framework. He frequently quotes himself, treating Stratechery as a journal of his evolving understanding rather than a series of standalone pieces.
  • Editing is relatively light. He reads everything out loud before publishing, which has nearly eliminated typos. He acknowledges that some pieces could use more trimming but accepts this as a trade-off of the daily deadline model.
  • Conclusions are challenging. The best ones tie back to the introduction. He sometimes pastes the introduction at the bottom of the draft while writing to keep the thread visible.

How the Internet Works: Thompson’s Framework

  • The internet has zero marginal costs and zero transaction costs, which fundamentally changes business models and strategy compared to the analog world.
  • In the analog world, distribution was the bottleneck, so power went to those who could get stuff to people. On the internet, everything is freely available, so the bottleneck becomes discovery.
  • This creates a barbell or smile curve effect: a few very large winners (Google, Facebook) that control discovery, and many small niche creators who can find their audience globally. Everyone in the middle is squeezed.
  • Traditional media companies cannot shrink enough because their cost structures were built for printing presses and delivery trucks. Individual creators have near-zero costs and can serve a global niche.
  • Thompson’s aggregation theory explains why platforms that control discovery get more users, which attracts more supply, creating a virtuous cycle that makes them dominant.
  • He argues that people underestimate the scale of the internet. Even capturing a tiny fraction of a global audience can be a viable business because the addressable market is billions of people.
  • Curation on the internet happens after publication (through algorithms and sharing) rather than before (through editors), which means massive volume of creation is encouraged because even if most content is low quality, the absolute amount of good content can be very large.

Advice for Creators

  • The most important article someone reads is the second one, because that is when they develop an expectation of consistency and quality.
  • Define your target audience and find your own pond rather than competing in a crowded space. Writers like Neil Cypert (Apple-focused) and Casey Newton (social media-focused) succeed by owning a specific niche.
  • Creativity is not a finite well; it replenishes through use. Making more content generates more ideas.
  • Writers should be confident in charging for their work and clearly articulate the value they provide. The reason to pay is not charity or wanting the writer to be popular; it is wanting access to the content.
  • Thompson started Stratechery with around 380 Twitter followers and no platform. Social media at the time rewarded sharing interesting links, which helped him grow. He acknowledges this is harder today because platforms suppress link-sharing.
  • He is temperamentally disagreeable, which he considers almost necessary for internet success because writers face constant public criticism and feedback that most people cannot handle.

Personal Habits and Background

  • Thompson grew up interested in technology but came from a blue-collar area where working in tech was not an obvious path. He was teaching English in Taiwan in his late twenties when his wife suggested he pursue tech, leading him to get an MBA as a way to gain legitimacy in the US job market.
  • The MBA gave him a language for concepts he already understood implicitly (leverage, margins, game theory) but he noticed the curriculum completely ignored the strategic implications of zero marginal costs, which became a foundational insight for Stratechery.
  • He lives in Taiwan, which creates a time zone challenge: mornings are occupied with US-based admin, interviews, and watching American sports. Writing typically happens in the late afternoon and evening after a period of procrastination and then panic as the deadline approaches.
  • He compresses his writing into three days per week (down from five), with the fourth day reserved for interviews. He describes himself as a procrastinator who is made productive by daily deadlines.
  • He reads intentionally and rapidly, often consuming an entire book in a morning when he needs to understand a topic for a piece. Clayton Christensen is his biggest intellectual influence.
  • He does not track his subscribers closely and prefers not to know when high-profile executives (including Fortune 5 CEOs) are reading, so it does not influence his writing. He values having no incentive to tell powerful people what they want to hear.

The Broader Impact

  • Thompson is widely credited with pioneering the paid newsletter model. The founders of Substack have explicitly cited him as inspiration.
  • He takes pride in the fact that Stratechery proved a single-person media company can compete with the largest media companies in the world on equal footing for audience time, with a radically different cost structure.
  • He believes his influence on technology companies is greater as an independent analyst than it would have been had he stayed in the corporate hierarchy, because CEOs value getting an honest outside perspective from someone with no incentive to flatter them.
Back to How I Write